Bill S-4 Energy Efficiency Act

Read Full Bill Text Here

S-4 An Act to Amend the Energy Efficiency Act

Bill Type: Senate Government Bill

Bill Sponsor: Hon. Sen. Pierre Moreau

Status: At Second Reading in the House of Commons. This Bill has not passed yet.

How would YOU vote? Scroll down to vote and comment below.

WHAT IS THIS BILL FOR?

Bill S-4 updates the Energy Efficiency Act — the Federal Law that sets rules for how energy-using products (appliances, equipment, technology) are made, labelled, imported and sold in Canada.

The Bill does four main things:

  • expands who the Law covers to include more businesses and modern technologies;
  • gives the Minister of Natural Resources new powers to grant exemptions from the rules
  • adds a new enforcement toolkit including fines, penalties and orders to fix problems
  • cracks down on false or misleading energy efficiency claims.

WHO GAINS POWER

The Minister of Natural Resources gains significant new authority under this Bill:

  • Power to grant exemptions from the Act for up to six months without public consultation and up to three years (extendable to six) through an application process
  • Power to order businesses to stop importing, shipping, labelling or selling a product if the Minister believes it violates the rules
  • Power to designate inspectors and enforcement officers
  • Power to access business premises remotely by telecommunications — without a warrant — as long as the owner is aware
  • Power to publish the names of businesses found to have violated the Act
  • Power to recover costs from businesses applying for exemptions

⚠️ Ministerial exemption orders — Orders made under sections 25.1 and 25.2 are explicitly excluded from the Statutory Instruments Act, meaning they do not go through the standard regulatory review process and are not subject to the same Parliamentary scrutiny as regulations.

⚠️ Remote inspection by telecommunications — Inspectors can enter a business's systems remotely without a warrant as long as the owner "is aware." The Bill does not define what "aware" means or require consent.

WHO LOSES POWER

  • Businesses (dealers and commercial entities) lose flexibility — the Act now covers a broader range of actors, including online advertisers and intermediaries who never physically handle products
  • Parliament loses oversight over ministerial exemption orders, which bypass the Statutory Instruments Act
  • Businesses seeking exemptions must pay cost-recovery fees to the Minister and have no guarantee of approval

WHO GAINS MONEY

  • Government gains cost-recovery revenue from businesses applying for exemptions under section 25.2
  • Consumers may benefit indirectly if stronger energy efficiency standards reduce energy costs over time

WHO LOSES MONEY

  • Businesses face significantly higher fines — up to $2,000,000 for a first indictable offense and $5,000,000 for subsequent offenses
  • Businesses face new administrative monetary penalties of up to $25,000 per violation, per day
  • Businesses applying for exemptions must pay processing and administration costs to the Minister
  • Businesses found in default of a compliance agreement face double the original penalty

THE CATCH

The exemption power is the one to watch. The Minister can exempt any person or product from any provision of the Act — including energy efficiency standards — for up to six years total. These orders bypass the Statutory Instruments Act, meaning they don't go through standard regulatory review, don't require Governor in Council approval and are not automatically tabled in Parliament for scrutiny.

⚠️ "Exceptional circumstance" — Section 25.1 allows the Minister to grant a six-month exemption to address "any exceptional circumstance that may arise." This term is not defined in the Bill, giving the Minister broad discretion to exempt products or businesses from energy efficiency rules without Parliamentary approval.

⚠️ Confidential exemption applications — Businesses can designate their exemption application information as confidential. The Minister cannot publish that information even when publishing the exemption order itself. The public sees the exemption exists but not the full reasoning behind it.

The enforcement framework is robust and the anti-greenwashing provisions (false energy efficiency claims) are a genuine improvement. But the exemption architecture creates a parallel regulatory stream that operates largely outside normal Parliamentary oversight.